I need to write a critique about a research article on Nutrition for my Nutrition class. I need an A!

Individual Journal Critique***YOU MUST SUBMIT A COPY OF THE ARTICLE YOU CRITIQUED ALONG WITH YOURCRITIQUE. IF A COPY OF THE ARTICLE IS NOT INCLUDED, YOU WILL GET A SCORE OFZERO***Objective:To evaluate the quality of a research article published in a nutrition-related peer-reviewed scientific journal. Determine if the published conclusions are supported by appropriate data correctly collected and interpreted. Assignment:Read a nutrition research article. Prepare detailed, accurate responses to thefollowing questions. Ideally, you will choose an article you will use in your team research project. (75 possible points for journal critique)Questions:1.Identify the article by writing the full citation. Use the AMA format shown herehttp://library.stkate.edu/sites/default/files/site… . (2 points)2. Identify theresearch category. This link describes the difference between analytical and descriptive research. http://www.dissertationindia.com/blog/descriptive-vs-analytical-approach-to-researcha.State if the research is primarily analytical or descriptive (1 point).b.State if the research is experimental or nonexperimental (1 point). (Experimental researchinvolves an active intervention compared to a nonexperimental trial which does not involve an active intervention.)If nonexperimental, state and briefly explain the type of research. (2 points)If experimental, name and describe the research design. (2 points)3.If the study isa.Experimental research, list the author’shypothesis [experimental research requires statement of a research question AND a hypothesis (null hypothesis). EXPERIMENTAL RESEACH IS WHEN THE RESEARCHER MANIPULATES THE INDEPENDENT VARIALBLE.b.If the study is nonexperimental, write theresearch question NONEXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH IS WHEN THE RESEARCHER IDENTIFIES BUT DOES NOTCONTROL THE INDEPENDENT VARIABLE.c. If the hypothesis or research question are not clearly stated in the article, then constructone. (2 points)4. List the author’sresearch objective(s). (2 points)5.Identify variables. (Watch this video to understand variables. Cut and paste this link into your browser to view the video. )a.If your article describes experimental research, identify, by listing and categorizing, themeasured dependent and independent research variables. For nonexperimental research, list all outcome measured variables. Be specific. (5 points)b.Identify confounding variables. List the confounding variables the authors needed tocontrol. Did authors identify and control for all confounding variables? (2 points)c.If the author did not describe confounding variables, list those you identify. (4 points)6.Discuss the research participants/units/groups of study.(The unit of analysis is the major entity analyzed in a study. It is the ‘what’ or ‘who’ that is being studied.)a. Describe in detail the units and procedures:1.Describe the units/subjects that were studied as they relate to the research article. (3 points)2. Describe the sample selection procedures. (3 points) (This is a helpful internetpage describing sample selection. http://korbedpsych.com/R06Sample.html )b. Explain why it is important to consider the research units when critiquing a research study. (2points)c. Describe why it would be problematic if the sample selection process was not random.(2 points)7. Is the research methodology employed clearly stated in such a way that other researchers couldrepeat this study? Answer yes or no. If not, which description(s) was (were) missing? For eitherresponse – explain, using examples from the research study, to justify your position. Thoroughly discuss to justify your answer. (6 points)8.Describe the study length.a. Identify, in weeks, months, or years, the exact time frame of each treatment in the researchstudy. (1 point)b. Was the time allotted sufficient to warrant meaningful conclusions? Explain your responsebased on logical, scientific rationales and provide “proof” for your response. (2 points)9. Discuss the statistical analysis of the results. I recommend that you visit statistics web sites andrelated textbooks for assistance with this section.a.List all of the statistical analyses methods utilized in this study. Describe the purpose of each of these statistical tests. (5 points)b. Was the statistical treatment of the data clearly defined and the statistics presented in astraightforward manner? Explain your response using ( at least 3 examples) of statistical findings discussed by the researchers. (3 points)10.By whom was the research sponsored? Could the results be influenced in any way by the sourceof funding? Explain your response. (2 points)11.Discuss the conclusions.a.How well were the conclusions drawn relate to the hypothesis (es) or research question.Explain your response based on logical, scientific rationales and provide “proof” for your response. (2 points)b.Was the hypothesis or research question supported or rejected? (1 point)c.Did the researcher compare the conclusions to any previous research conclusions/literature?Explain your response, using (at least 2) examples. (2 points)d.Was the conclusion convincing? That is, are the conclusions that the researcher presentedjustified by the facts uncovered by the study? Explain your response using at least (4examples). (4 points)12. Are the methods, data, and conclusions presented sufficiently strong to generalize the results beyond the scope of the study participants? Thoroughly and logically justify your answer. (5points)13.Discuss areas of future research.a.List(at least 2) potential applications and recommendations for future research applicationsthat were included by the researcher. (2 points)b.Suggest (at least 3) areas of further research, relevant to this research, that were notsuggested by the researcher. (3 points)14.How would you, as a researcher, improve this study? Provide(at least 4) specific ideas for improvement. (4 points)Remember to submit a copy of the journal article you are critiquing. Submit your assignment via drop box on D2L. This assignment is DUE the end of week 12. (NOVEMBER 18TH)

Need Help Writing an Essay?

Tell us about your assignment and we will find the best writer for your paper.

Write My Essay For Me

“Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!”